Those trying to use their credit card for wagering at an online casino and
sportsbook have certainly noticed problems getting authorization for
approval. The problem in most cases is not the individual's credit line,
but changes in the policies of Visa and MasterCard that have rejected the
transaction.
In some cases, players have attempted to make deposits using up to 4 credit
cards and found each was denied. In some cases, a 5th credit card would work.
What's causing the problem? Simple. Visa and MasterCard decided that they
do not desire to process gaming transactions. They offered the merchant
banks a code to identify the merchant (casino/sportsbook) as a gaming
operation. This code is known as "7995." Its one of the ugliest numbers in
the online gaming industry, as it has caused a decline in industry
revenues, most operators say it is off by 30% compared to last year.
The code is based on the old Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) code
and identifies the type of business the merchant is engaged in.
What happens is an issuing bank (example: Providian Bank) codes the
processor of an online casino or sportsbook (the merchant) as 7995.
Whenever a Providian Bank based credit card is used from a player and
authorization is attempted from that casino, the 7995 code comes up in
VISA's database. Subsequently the approval for the charge is denied. The
player tries to use another credit card issued from another bank,
attempting to see if that gets through. The player does this until (1)
he/she gets the charge accepted and starts to wager, or (2) he/she runs out
of credit cards.
The 7995 program was first introduced by Visa in late 2001. It was strictly
voluntary for the merchant bank to implement. Providian was one of the
first to use the system. As they are one of the largest merchant banks,
their effect on the gaming industry was felt almost immediately. Other
merchant banks soon followed. MasterCard initiated a similar system on May
1, 2002. Most, but not all issuing banks now use the 7995 code.
Its impact to the online gaming industry and the frustrations it has
brought to the player have sprung up another business: Alternative Payment
Processing. Paypal was one of the first and most aggressive players to
enter this niche market. Their rapid growth was significant (mostly from
i-gaming as well as eBay). They were purchased by eBay last summer for US
$1.4 Billion (a mind boggling figure). The purchase also resulted in an
announcement that Paypal would no longer be involved with i-gaming
transactions. On November 25, 2002 Paypal became officially "out" of the
online gaming e-commerce business.
Enter new players into the Alternative Payment Processing market: Neteller,
now the market leader, followed by many companies that want a piece of the
online gaming e-commerce pie. Internet Cash Card, PayManager, ProCyber,
900pay, e-Gold, OneWPS, etc. It is a confusing situation for an operator.
One wants to choose an alternative payment system that is reliable and will
not need to be switched again over the next 2 to 4 years. It is costly for
an operator to switch its players to a new payment system, as they tend to
lose customers in the process.
The ASROC conference (http://www.asroc.com) on January 7, 2003 is a one day
event on Alternative Payment Processing for internet businesses, with a
focus on online gaming. The conference is designed so that numerous
alternative payment processing systems can show their wares to many savvy
casino/sportsbook operators. The idea behind it is that the next "Paypal"
will be found at this event. Most likely 3 or 4 systems will be selected by
consensus from the operators. By spring they will most likely be
implemented with the online casino/sportsbooks, and by fall of 2003 most
players should be using the new systems. The conference will be held on
January 7, 2003 at the Hotel Real Inter-Continental in San Jose, Costa Rica.
Despite the 7995 code, many casinos/sportsbooks are able to get around the
code. How they do this is quite simple. The merchant sticks with a payment
processor until the casino/sportsbook is "e;coded"e; 7995 and no longer
processes VISA/MasterCard transactions. At that time the casino/sportsbook
switches their merchant bank to another payment processor and starts anew
until they are coded again. The coding of 7995 from the new payment
procesor can take anywhere from a few days, a week, or even a month. It
reminds me of the old college days of "phone phreaking" when a hacker
friend would find telephone calling card numbers from a multinational
Fortune 500 corporation, and then provide half the college campus with it.
Everyone would use the calling codes to call all over the world. It would
take anywhere from two weeks to 2 months for the Fortune 500 company to see
a whopping phone bill. Once the calling card number was cancelled, the
hacker friend would provide 5 new ones. And so on and so on.
Leave the world alone like this and the casinos/sportsbooks will get around
it. But it doesn't work so fast. Visa is instituting a "Verified by Visa"
policy, which from what we hear is to be officially started in Spring 2003.
It requires both the consumer to verify their identity and the merchant to
be certified as to their business practices.
Here's how it is set to work:
VERIFICATION (FOR THE CONSUMER): Each Visa cardholder will have to register
their Visa card online and generate a password (or PIN). This password will
be used for ALL online transactions (including airline tickets, books,
etc). This verification policy will ensure the cardholder is the owner of
the card and serves as an extra level of security.
CERTIFICATION (FOR THE MERCHANT): Each merchant will be certified with
their payment processor. This is important, as merchants will be coded as
to their business practices. Online casinos, currently coded as 7995 and
rejected in most cases, will be under further scrutiny. The intermediary
bank or the issuing bank doesn't want to get blacklisted with VISA, so they
will attempt to ensure that each merchant is properly certified.
What this means for iGaming is that come springtime 2003, reliable
alternative payment processing systems need to be in place or soon
thereafter a severe drop off in online transactions is expected to take
place. (Sources have informed us that MasterCard is looking to create a
similar policy - and soon). The verification/certification policy is
borderless, meaning that an online gaming operation operating in a licensed
jurisdiction will still see revenues drop due to rejections from credit cards.
And for the casinos/sportsbooks that avoided the 7995 code by continually
switching payment processors and/or merchant banks, they will have to
submit for re-certification each time, a lengthy process.
What's interesting is that we have heard through the grapevine that most
casinos and sportsbook operators in the Caribbean and in Europe have for
the most part ignored Visa's new "Verified by Visa" policy and turned a
blind eye to it. We also keep hearing that Visa is DEAD serious about this
policy.
The verification policy came not from a crack down on i-Gaming but from
requests from retail online merchants, who were complaining about fraud and
charge backs. This places the liability more on the issuing bank and less
so on Visa or the merchant. Online merchants not in i-gaming are actually
happy with this policy.
The ASROC conference has a senior analyst from the Gartner Group providing
a 45 minute session scheduled just for this and will most likely be
discussed at length with additional speakers.
A tremendous opportunity has come for the internet in terms of creating a
new alternative payment processing industry. Each of these companies
looking for rapid growth are focusing on the online gaming industry as a
major source of income. Whatever happens in the future, Alternative Payment
Processing for the internet is here to stay, and we should be one of the
first to see it.
Marc Lesnick runs StartCasino.com, an information site for gaming
executives on starting a casino business and a directory of the online
gaming industry. Mr. Lesnick both consults with gaming executives and
speaks at numerous industry conferences.